Two Quail West houses closed on the same day, September 10, 2026. 4517 Brynwood Drive has 9,667 square feet and sold for $7,000,000. 4297 Deephaven Lane has 5,173 square feet and sold for $6,850,000. The two prices are $150,000 apart, but the Brynwood house is close to twice the size. Brynwood was built in 2013. Deephaven is a McGarvey-built Fairview model from 2021.
That pair is a small version of the whole market inside the gates. In Quail West, the year a home was built moves its price more than its square footage does. Over the last 12 months, the newest homes tended to be the smaller ones, and they sold for more in total dollars than original estates with thousands of extra square feet. Sorting the listings by build year explains most of the price gaps that square footage leaves unexplained.
The past year's sales, sorted by build year
This table lists closed sales from November 2025 through September 2026, ordered from newest construction to oldest.
| Address | Year built | Sq ft | Sold price | $/sq ft | Closed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6199 Highcroft Dr | 2023 | 5,055 | $8,000,000 | $1,582 | May 19, 2026 |
| 6253 Highcroft Dr | 2022 | 4,795 | $6,175,000 | $1,287 | Dec 1, 2025 |
| 4297 Deephaven Ln | 2021 | 5,173 | $6,850,000 | $1,324 | Sept 10, 2026 |
| 5949 Sunnyslope Dr | 2020 | 4,931 | $7,550,000 | $1,531 | May 20, 2026 |
| 4517 Brynwood Dr | 2013 | 9,667 | $7,000,000 | $724 | Sept 10, 2026 |
| 28790 Blaisdell Dr | 2002 | 8,879 | $4,500,000 | $506 | May 11, 2026 |
| 6489 Highcroft Dr | 2001 | 6,272 | $3,600,000 | about $574 | Feb 27, 2026 |
| 13700 Pondview Cir | 1997 | 7,217 | $4,650,000 | $644 | Apr 15, 2026 |
| 4484 Brynwood Dr | 1994 | 6,213 | $3,600,000 | about $579 | June 29, 2026 |
All four homes built in the 2020s fall in a narrow band of 4,795 to 5,173 square feet. All four sold for between $6.1 million and $8.0 million. The listing for 6199 Highcroft marked it as new construction, and the listing for 6253 Highcroft credits Diamond Custom Homes as the builder. The original 1990s and early-2000s houses run from 6,200 to nearly 8,900 square feet and closed between $3.6 million and $4.65 million. So during the last year, the most expensive way to buy in Quail West was to buy the least house.
The pattern also shows up in how long homes sat and how much sellers gave up. 4297 Deephaven sold in 16 days at 97.9% of its asking price. 28790 Blaisdell took 518 days and closed at 90.5% of list.
Size pulls the per-foot price down, too
The 4517 Brynwood sale shows that build year isn't the only factor. That house went up in 2013, which is newer than every original estate in the table, yet it closed at $724 a square foot. The likely reason is its size. At 9,667 square feet, every extra room spreads the price across more footage, and buyers here have not paid a premium per foot for that much space. 28790 Blaisdell is the same story with an older house: 8,879 square feet built in 2002, sold at $506 a foot.
So when you compare two Quail West listings, check two numbers before the price: the year built and the square footage. A newer home of about 5,000 square feet and a 1990s home of about 7,000 square feet are in different price brackets, even though they share a gate, a clubhouse and 36 holes of Arthur Hills golf.
Renovation is how an older house reaches the newer prices
Some older Quail West homes do sell at new-construction prices, and the listings show how. 4468 Brynwood Drive was built in 2012, listed as fully renovated, and sold in November 2025 for $6,125,000, or $1,231 a square foot. 6441 Highcroft Drive was built in 2001 and remodeled in 2024. It sold in December 2025 for $4,800,000, also at $1,231 a foot. That number sits in the same range as the homes built in 2021 and 2022.
The highest price ever paid in Quail West also went to an older house. Naples Press reported that 4300 Brynwood Drive sold for $11.3 million. The home was built in 1995, renovated with custom finishes, and sits on a 2.2-acre double lot. The paper put the price at about $1,013 a square foot and said it beat the previous high, an $8.55 million sale in September 2023, by 32%. The sale closed April 8, 2026.
At the other end, 4484 Brynwood Drive went to market as a 1994 house "designed with future renovations in mind." It closed in June 2026 at $3.6 million. In this market, that price buys you the land and the club access, and you supply the update. A buyer comparing it with a $6 million home on Highcroft is really comparing a finished product with an unfinished one.
The one empty homesite, and what building would cost
Starting from bare ground is the other route to a new house in Quail West, and right now there is only one lot to do it on. 4485 Brynwood Drive is listed at $2,525,000 for 1.05 acres, and the existing house has already been torn down. Its listing calls it "the ONLY available homesite in Quail West," says it borders a 100-acre nature preserve, and comes with two pre-sited plans from RG Designs: a 4,500-square-foot plan and a 5,700-square-foot plan. The listing says the plans can shorten the build by up to six months. It also says builders have bid the plans "starting at $550 price per square foot." As of mid-November, the lot is still listed as active.
Here is the arithmetic on those published figures. The 4,500-square-foot plan at $550 a foot comes to $2,475,000 in construction. Add the $2,525,000 asking price and you get $5,000,000, or about $1,111 a square foot all-in. The 5,700-square-foot plan works out to $3,135,000 in construction, or $5,660,000 with the lot, which is about $993 a foot. Both totals assume the starting bid and the full asking price, and they don't include upgrades, design changes or the months spent building.
Even with those limits, the math puts the finished resales in context. The 2021 and 2022 homes in the table sold for $1,287 to $1,324 a square foot. Paying that much buys a finished house without a construction schedule. With time to wait, someone could build a home of similar size on this lot for less, on paper, if the bids hold.
What the community-wide median is blending together
The single number you'll see on a portal mixes all of these homes together. Across Quail West, the September 2026 median was $990 a square foot. The 12-month average through mid-November was $975 a square foot on 40 sales, and the 12-month average sale price was $4,575,567. Very few homes in the table actually sold anywhere near $975 a foot. The newer homes sold well above it and the original estates sold well below it, so the average describes a house that hardly exists.
The overall pace matters for both kinds of homes. Nothing closed in October 2026. As of that report, 19 homes were for sale at a median asking price of $3.95 million, which is about 11.4 months of supply at the sales pace of the prior three months. The same report notes that roughly six months is usually considered balanced. Over the 12 months through mid-November, only 8% of Quail West sales closed at or above the asking price. The largest discounts went to homes that sat longest. 28740 Blaisdell Drive, a 6,814-square-foot home, sold in August 2026 after 324 days at 85.2% of list.
For a seller, this points to one practical question: does your home's condition put it with the 2020s builds or with the 1990s estates? We wrote about pricing that decision in selling a luxury estate home in Quail West. Our Pine Ridge post looks at a similar two-market split a few miles south.
The club's minimum membership costs the same at every price
The required minimum membership is the same for every house in the table. Under the club's 2026–2027 membership schedule, House Membership is the minimum required for property owners. It has a $100,000 initiation fee, $13,100 in annual operating dues, and annual capital dues of $1,500 or $3,000. A $10,000 transfer fee replaces the initiation fee when a resale home comes with a transferable House Membership. Full Golf costs $250,000 to join and $24,940 a year in operating dues, or a $25,000 transfer fee when a transferable golf membership comes with the home. The same schedule lists a lot transfer fee of one-half of 1% of the sale price, so that one charge does rise with the price of the house. These are general figures for the 2026–2027 season, not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm your own membership terms with the club and your advisors before you make an offer. A $100,000 House Membership initiation is a larger share of a $3.6 million original than of an $8 million new build. Our posts on Grey Oaks and Mediterra show how two nearby clubs structure the same decision.
FAQ
Is an original 1990s home in Quail West a teardown? None of these sales was recorded as a land-only purchase. 4484 Brynwood was marketed for renovation and sold as a house. The best-documented renovation result is the $11.3 million record at 4300 Brynwood, a 1995 home on a double lot.
How many homes are built new in Quail West each year? Quail West has roughly 700 home sites, and its one listed vacant homesite is the Brynwood lot. That means new homes here come mainly from rebuilding on existing lots and from homes built in the last few years coming up for resale.
If you're comparing a 2020s Quail West resale with an original estate you could renovate, or running the numbers on the Brynwood lot, Armand Alikaj can line up the build year, square footage and sale history for each home on your list. Call or text to start a personalized Naples market consultation, or see our Quail West community page.